top of page

The Church and the Mind

21 hours ago
3 min read

As a believing mental health professional for twenty years, I am astonished at the organized church's refusal to acknowledge the basic functioning of the human body and human needs. I accept that much of life contains mystery. I see great value in faith beyond "solid facts". But making religion into a dreamy, dramatic, constantly glorious dance with the divine is silly. Humans have bodies, so religion needs teeth.


We're not divinely wispy souls trapped annoyingly in fleshy bodies. Our souls have bodies ON PURPOSE. Not only are those bodies vulnerable, they are also vessels for connection, receptors of great damage, and empowered to impact the world around us. If we remain ignorant to how they work, or refuse to utilize them as they're designed, we fail to steward our one wild and precious life.


I am still reading Beth Moore's All My Knotted Up Life memoir. My favorite thing in the last chapter is her recognition that once the ego has been crushed, it never fully recovers (thank God). Her own bouts with depression, intense disassociation, marital trouble, parenting failures and abuse took her to a place where she knows she can't judge others. But I am still confounded by her avoidance to call mental health what it is and to tie healing to a very practical, tangible practice we know to be psychology.


Psychology is not the antithesis of faith. In fact, in my experience, it most often empowers a deepening of one's spirituality, rather than a destruction. That process often comes with a burning off of any falseness that has encumbered.


A differentiated therapist validates experience and makes space for meaning. A well-trained therapist supports their clients to be set free from relational damage and mental anguish. A humble therapist knows they are not the Ultimate Healer, they are just trained in the art of healing. They know they are perfectly poised to see the infection, calling it out for what it is, stripping it of the power of shame and pointing the wounded toward the door of freedom. Good therapists are deeply compassionate and have had to do their own intense personal reflection and healing work to be able to walk steadily when the road is rocky.


Ms. Moore so far barely acknowledges the real, namable afflictions she's experienced. She cloaks them in dramatic language like darkness and the devil. She sometimes describes the abusive, manipulative behavior of others and then directly calls those others NOT abusive manipulators. It's confusing at best.


She tallies her own lax boundaries as equally "sinful" with abuse. Those things are not equal. Certainly they're both problematic. Of course both are "less than ideal." But abusing power by harming those who are beholden to you is not equal to letting your kids have too much cheese on their hamburgers (one of her few actual, tangible examples).


When a pastor forces you, a victim of unprocessed sexual abuse who has no training in healing, to counsel another victim through the telling of the gruesome details of their own abuse, what did you think was going to happen? She even says she felt it "might be" wrong before she engaged and yet after all that resulted, still doesn't say outright that not only she, but also the demanding pastor were wrong and could have (should have!) sought help from a professional trained in the healing of the mind!


Why are we continuing to suggest that waving a mystical, magical wand we call Jesus has a better effect than engaging the real, practical tools of psychology we have learned through the legacy of human history--a gift of God itself!?!


I am not against Jesus. The actual Jesus anyway. The middle eastern man who walked the earth about two-thousand years ago, who embodied the personhood of God, who offers Himself as a perfect connection to the divine, both in his life and his death and resurrection. I like that guy. I love him actually. I would be lost without him. And he gave me psychology.


Can we stop suggesting that psychology and religion oppose one another? Psychology wants what we all want--healing and wholeness. Psychology has teeth. Within it are evidence-based practices, tried and true, that have proven themselves over and over to enable fellow created humans to be set free. Can we honor God with acknowledging what works? Can we give credit where credit is due? It's not magic, it just works.



Subscribe to the blog for honest stories delivered straight to your inbox.

To sign up to receive my free guides, see here.

Thanks for subscribing!

bottom of page