top of page

Pretty Bows

I recently hunted for a new devotional because the one I'd been using was becoming disappointingly evangelistic in the way that smells more like pop cultural imperialism than actually sharing the love of Christ.


I decided unconventionally to jump into Beth Moore's autobiography All My Knotted Up Life, reading a chapter per morning, because I figured listening to the honest testimony of a fellow believer ought to help me see the love of God more clearly through the lens of the Body of Christ.


She's a good writer. She's funny and succinct. She's from Arkansas, where I live, and animated in her story telling. But I'm about half way through now and there are some things that are rubbing me the wrong way.


I have long known about Beth Moore because she is a famously female bible teacher. As a woman who enjoys teaching myself, I've always considered her a bit of a frontrunner in opportunities for women in the Body of Christ. She notoriously has refused positions that sound like that they could be anywhere near teaching men, as she belongs to the Southern Baptist tradition of patriarchy, which refuses women the right to any form of authority over men. Twenty years ago, when I began teaching, I agreed with her.


Over time I've changed my mind to believe that women are equally capable of teaching all genders and ought to be supported in those opportunities. But it is fascinating to me that Ms. Moore has held out as long as she has. She is highly respected in the American Christian culture and sets the tone and standard for a lot of women.


My first problem with this autobiography is Ms. Moore's stance on her marriage. She hasn't gone into great detail, but her incredibly cryptic description of her husband's mental health issues and behavior smell like psychological abuse and emotional neglect. She remains in her marriage, which I respect as one-hundred percent her choice. What I have a problem with is the absence of any condemnation for his bad behavior.


Not calling bad things "bad" is a way of implying they are not bad. She says those experiences were "hard" and then immediately claims her own behavior as seemingly, equally hard. She implies his behavior was excusable. She points to mental illness as a justification. Which means the next time something like that happens to any one of us, we are encouraged to accept it and allow it to continue.


No one is held accountable.


This same problem shows up a couple of chapters later in the manipulative bullying of one SBC pastor regarding Ms. Moore's church membership. This may seem like a petty fight to pick, but the result of that bad behavior resulted in a huge shift in Ms. Moore's life. A shift that affected her whole family and the entire community she left in passive submission to a self-centered, power hungry authority figure. Ms. Moore then ties up that experience with a pretty bow suggesting that, though she didn't want to make the move, her obedience was blessed with countless opportunities. Of course it was. The patriarchy superficially rewards those who cower.


Again, bad behavior isn't called "bad". In fact, she reframes this round as good! And not in the "God redeems all bad things" kind of way! Rather, Ms. Moore is suggesting that even when you smell a rat, just keep going as if it doesn't stink. Accept your stinky fate and just believe that bad things are hiddenly good.


Nope. Not anymore. Not for me. Bad things are bad. Let's call them what they are. Sometimes you don't have a choice about the bad things that happen to you, but usually your intuition is right. When a bad thing is happening in which you do have a choice, choose to do something about it! Choose to stand against!


Please, believers! Please wake up and smell the stink! Stop framing your bad things as good. Believe your nose. Believe your gut! Dare I say, believe the Holy Spirit prompting you to STOP and move against the things that are bad. It doesn't take "faith" to call bad things good. That's willful ignorance you're practicing!


Practicing a true faith would be to step up against the bad things amidst great fear, believing you carry more with you in your obstinance than your own little will. Believe that the good God who loves you stands with you and will come alongside your effort to resist evil in the world, even though it may cost you dearly. It may cost you stability. It may cost you a job, an opportunity, or the good graces of the patriarchy around you.


I'm only half way through Ms. Moore's book. I don't dislike her. I know she's made some choices in her life that I whole-heartedly agree with. I look forward to hearing the rest of the story. I don't regret using this as a devotional. But I will be moving forward with caution. There are some parts of her story I hope not to emulate.



Subscribe to the blog for honest stories delivered straight to your inbox.

To sign up to receive my free guides, see here.

Thanks for subscribing!

bottom of page